Did You Expect These 10 Must-Play Games on Game Pass? You’ll Be Surprised! - Carbonext

Understanding the Context

Before exploring the surprises, it’s worth noting why Game Pass has redefined gaming access. With hundreds of AAA titles available at a monthly or yearly fee—no DLC pressure, no split purchases—it’s a playground for all skill levels and genres. But beyond the big-name exclusives, Game Pass curators consistently uncover hidden treasures that catch even veteran players off guard.

Surprise Must-Play Games You Didn’t Expect

Here are 10 standout picks from the “Did You Expect These 10 Must-Play Games on Game Pass?” roundup that truly impressed players worldwide:

1. Disco Elysium – The Final Quest
   An RPG masterpiece with deep narrative and mental skill checks, Disco Elysium feels like a literary experience set in a crime noir world. Many were surprised by its raw storytelling and unique gameplay loop—defying expectations of what a “walking simulator” could offer.

Key Insights

2. Hive
   A tactical roguelike with stunning psychedelic visuals, Hive blends intense mech combat with a rich sci-fi narrative. Players often cited its “addictive depth” and creative battle systems as standout features rarely found in the genre.

3. The Ascent
   A side-scrolling bullet-hell shooter with multiplayer PvP and mind-bending levels, The Ascent delivered pure adrenaline. Many were stunned by its polished combat and magnetic charm, turning casual players into seasoned speedrunners.

4. Farming Simulator 19 (with new content updates)
   While not new, Farmer Simulator’s ongoing support and seasonal updates caught the attention of gamers expecting just the “big hits.” The realistic farming mechanics and deep lifestyle immersion made it a hidden gem, especially for relaxing yet rewarding gameplay.

5. Return of the Obra Dinn
   Once a cult title, Obra Dinn’s eerie detective adventure stunned fans with its haunting atmosphere and ingenious puzzle design. Its mix of storytelling and exploration exceeded many preconceptions about narrative-driven indie games.

6. Outer Wilds: Enhanced Edition (via Game Pass)
   The critically beloved space mystery saw new light thanks to Game Pass accessibility. The enhanced version brought improved controls and visuals, making its existential puzzlegame even more approachable and revealing.

Final Thoughts

7. Genshin Impact – Shadow Souls Expansion (via Game Pass)
   Not a full title, but the expansion pack brought new combat mechanics and playstyles that surprised players craving fresh challenges. The smooth integration with Game Pass optimized roaming made this a must-try.

8. Tunic (via emulation proof and indie coverage in Game Pass)
   While not fully released yet, announced exclusives and indie buzz amplified interest. Gamers speculated on its raw, atmospheric adventure style, and early leaks raised expectations far above typical discovery.

9. Slay the Spire: Classic Edition
   This tower defense roguelike’s blend of strategy and RPG elements resonated deeply with fans. Surprisingly accessible to newcomers, it delivered intense replayability and smart mechanics rarely found in the genre.

10. Marship Diary: Voyager’s End
    A narrative-rich narrative-driven shooter with unique time-motion mechanics, Voyager’s story and pacing exceeded many expectations. The Game Pass release expanded accessibility, making it a standout for players seeking emotional depth.

Why Gamers Were Surprised

What made these titles shine was their ability to deliver powerful experiences beyond mainstream perspectives—games that balance innovative mechanics with compelling storytelling. Many players assumed Game Pass was all about blockbusters, but this curated list proves it’s also a showcase for quality gaming at your fingertips, no matter your spending threshold.